California union's billionaire tax bid revives state-level wealth tax push
The SEIU-backed 'billionaire tax' ballot initiative in California represents a renewed progressive attempt to impose a wealth tax on state residents, reviving a national debate about state-level wealth taxation amid federal inaction.
The SEIU California union's push for a 'billionaire tax' ballot initiative reflects a longstanding progressive strategy to bypass federal gridlock on wealth taxation by acting at the state level. The initiative would impose a roughly 1.5% annual tax on net worth above $1 billion, generating projected $5-8 billion per year for healthcare, education, and homelessness programs — directly countering the federal administration's refusal to raise taxes on the ultra-wealthy after the Trump-era Tax Cuts and Jobs Act's individual provisions expire in 2025. The real story is whether this model — which faces constitutional challenges under the California Constitution's uniformity clause and property tax limitations, as similar proposals have in other states — can survive legal scrutiny and serve as a template for other blue states seeking to tax wealth hidden in assets rather than income.
The humanitarian alternative
A more legally durable alternative would pair a modest state wealth tax with a federal-state partnership: a national wealth surtax of 2% on net worth above $50 million, which the IRS could administer using existing reporting from banks and financial institutions. This avoids state-level valuation disputes and capital flight risks, while raising an estimated $200 billion/year that could fund universal healthcare expansion and child poverty reduction. Alternatively, a progressive state-level 'mark-to-market' tax on unrealized capital gains above $100 million for publicly-traded assets — already suggested by legal scholars — would be easier to administer and less vulnerable to constitutional challenge.
Falsifiable predictions
What this entry claims will happen, and what data would prove it wrong. The Reckoner revisits these against current reality.
- The California billionaire tax will face a legal challenge within 30 days of qualifying for the ballot, citing the dormant Commerce Clause or due process.
- If the measure qualifies for the November 2026 ballot, the union's campaign spending will exceed $50 million total by Election Day.
Original source — excerpted
news Billionaire tax union burns big money on hotels, breathing 'coach'"See more of our coverage in your search results. One of California’s biggest healthcare unions defied Gov. Gavin Newsom by placing a billionaire tax on the b..."